Beach to Bay Seafood Company

We came to visit from the UK and we were not disappointed. The soft crab sandwich was to die for, we had a seafood platter too which was incredible. What's more the owner is lovely, the vibe is amazing and the cinnamon rice pudding.... Wow!
Sure, the service system is quirky, but to us, that's part of the charm of this place. The food speaks for its self.

My boyfriend has been hyping this place up to me for years and today I finally made it! The crabcakes are so delicious, filled with flaky crab and very little to no filler/breading. Hush puppies tasted amazing with the homemade tartar sauce. Not a huge fan of potato salad, but this was some of the best I've ever eaten. It was all light and tasty. Inside dining is closed but it was the perfect day to sit and eat at the picnic table and enjoy the weather

Wow. We are staying in a home on Deal Island for vacation & so happy previous Google reviewers steered us toward this place (thank you!). We all got different combos and sides and there wasn’t anything we didn’t thoroughly enjoy! Kicking myself for turning down the rice pudding for dessert! (Though not sure we’d have room.. but might go back for lunch and rice pudding tomorrow!) Easy call-to-order, seamless pickup with very pleasant gentleman and woman at the windows, & 10/10 food.. & plenty of it! Pic attached of my combo #1 with sides of hush puppies & beets! Will include on our VRBO review as well! Wouldn’t want anyone to miss this place!

Edited to update: went back for lunch and got the rice pudding (with the cinnamon). Let’s just say we won’t skip it next time! So good.