Smith Island Baking Company

I highly recommend a visit to this unique piece of Americana. I called ahead and requested a “shipping ready” cake so I could bring it on my road trip and surprise my friends 1,000 miles away, 2-days later. The folks there are super friendly and I really enjoyed meeting them. The cake made it perfectly and blew my friends away!

Ordered a vanilla birthday cake from Goldbelly. BEST CAKE EVER!!!!! Buttercream is absolutely perfect. I couldn’t have made it better. Layers were perfection too. Cake was packaged wonderfully. I couldn’t be happier. You can tell the cakes are handmade too. This review is coming from a family of “from scratch” bakers. A+, highly recommend you order a cake from this company for your special occasion!!!

2022:
I Had pre-ordered the birthday package and sent it to myself in SW Ohio and it arrived on the date I specified exactly.(I gave a 1.5 week notice) It was packaged 100% perfect and everything was frozen and intact. It was a Styrofoam cooler with dry ice packed with a nondescript overbox. Price was a bit high but worth it. The only weird thing is it's made in Crisfield, not Ewell. Close enough though, still 100% great experience. The package included 4 pints of the ice cream, the original large cake, candles and chocolates. The reason I ordered this cake was their 100% guarantee, made me feel safer in my decision. I really need to get back to the island, but this time the taste of the island came to me. What a great birthday it was, it truly made my year!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2023: This time I ordered the Double Chocolate Raspberry cake. It came on time and in perfect condition again. Ice cream was frozen and hard, everything was good. The Old Bay ice cream was interesting. Hmmm. I included some photos.